Talk:Upcoming ERB suggestions/@comment-4328703-20141229015032

In the description of Cobain and Hendrix it says:

(rock and roll musicians from Seattle who died at the age of 27)

This should probably changed to something else because being from Seattle and dying at a certain age does not qualify a match-up for a battle. Bill Gates is from Seattle, does that mean he should battle Hendrix? no. Jim Morrison died at the age of 27, does that mean he should battle Cobain? not at all. While these two things are similar, they hardly make a solid connection.

If the connection is changed to Rock and Roll musicians who lead famous music groups of 3 who both played guitar, while that still in my mind is a bad connection, its atleast better than two random coincidences like their age of death and home city.

While I personally don't like the idea, it did make it up at the top of the list, so while we do keep it there, we should most likely change the reason behind putting them in a battle.