Talk:Sir Isaac Newton vs Bill Nye/@comment-5585392-20140616194026/@comment-5264252-20140617053542

Smeagol vs Gollum was mediocre at best. Fawkes vs Joker was great until Joker focused too much on sex and rape jokes. Best fanmade I've ever seen was the TV Villains Versus Darth Vader battle.

On topic, Harry Potter vs Harry Houdini is definitely ERB material. Harry Potter is iconic enough to be different enough from Dumbledore in their battle. They'd planned to use him against Edward Cullen in Season 1, but scrapped it simply because it didn't turn out well.