User blog comment:Drakan95/L vs Sherlock Holmes. Epic Rap Battles: Cartoons vs History. Season 2/@comment-26966462-20151109134223/@comment-5264252-20151110073321

I like Luffy vs Blackbeard more because more history to it and it provides more contrast, but Blackbeard is a character in One Piece, and scrolling through his page, he seems to be a pretty important one at that, and while I think a rival-ish match-up would be cool to see, Blackbeard seems to be almost too major in One Piece to really be an entirely different character that Luffy faces. If that makes sense?? idk. Over all, Luffy vs Sparrow would probably be better.

Luffy vs Popeye is best Luffy match-up, but Popeye is definitely cartoons.