Talk:Season 4/@comment-75.74.44.118-20141228031100/@comment-25867520-20141228142110

I agree it's one-sided and the people who have been pushing for this are 1D fans. However, the more I think about it, the more I actually don't mind it. It would be good to see all the Beatles but it would be good for them to take on their equivalent today. Now before you shout down my neck, no, I don't mean talent-wise. The Beatles did start out as a boy band, girls were all over them and most people can name all the members. Obviously they changed their style but they were the original boy band. It would be interesting to see ERB do a traditional boy band like 1D.

However if the Beatles take on a proper good band, I would say the Rolling Stones cause they were rivals at one point. But if it's Beatles vs. 1D, I don't mind!