User blog comment:Eminemgoeswild/ horror villain characters cast prediction/@comment-28938497-20150913153802

Why does everyone say Markiplier as Slenderman? He's not even slender. He's muscular. Such bad casting! If he'd be anyone on this list, it'd be the Wolfman.

Really, Nice Peter should play Slenderman, as he has the right height and build, and could do the voice perfectly too.

Also, Peter shouldn't be Freddy. I just don't see that working.