User blog comment:Hippie Rat/Hippie Rat Reviews - Dragonsblood23's Harry Potter VS Spider-Man/@comment-9623756-20170116025529

Right off the bat you come off as pretentious when you tell us that you think people only dislike the suggestion because Spiderman vs Tarzan. That is quite clearly not true. I have expresssed on multiple occassions why I dislike the matchup, and it has nothing to do with other (admittedly better) Spidey suggestions. It has to do with the fact that it relies on side connections (ie rich villains, fighting reptiles) that are poor and vague, and the fact that, besides these, it is just essentially a battle based on two characters who fit the standard story of parents dying and going to live with an uncle. You know who else fits this? Luke, Eragon, Matilda (iirc), Jon Snow (twice). It doesn't work on an essential level.