Talk:Deadpool vs Boba Fett/@comment-26947829-20150923230558/@comment-5482968-20150923231946

Smith played an old man wearing a young man's skin. Plus, we just got back to having an older Doctor after 2 increasingly young ones. To go back again to a young one so soon after, when the Doctor has for the majority of the show's existence been older, seems both unlikely and a bit annoying, especially when crotchety Capaldi has been so enjoyable.

Not to mention, one look at this guy and he doesn't feel particularly "Doctorish". First, the beard would probably need to go, as facial hair isn't something the Doctor really ought to wear. Second, Madden's fairly "traditionally handsome". The Doctor, while made into a heartthrob at times by fangirls (boys too), has never really been "traditionally" handsome. A suave, "manly" Doctor is something that's never really existed. He's always been an oddball, and this incarnation shouldn't deviate from that.

That last part sounded a bit fanboyish, I must say.